How to tell if supplements are fake: 8 checks before you buy or take them
How to spot counterfeit or tainted supplements bought online: seller, packaging and lot numbers, what a barcode can and cannot tell you, warning ingredients on the label, and the official lists to search (FDA, Korea, Japan).
Supplements are expensive and mostly bought online, so counterfeits and products with ingredients that should not be there do get sold. Products sold for weight loss, muscle building, sexual enhancement or "focus" are the ones most often found with hidden drug ingredients. In the US, dietary supplements are not approved by the FDA before they go on sale, so a lot of the checking falls on the buyer. Here are eight checks you can do at home.
1. Where you buy matters most
The brand's own store or an authorised retailer is the safest. On marketplaces, look at who the actual seller is, how long they have been selling and where returns go. A price far below everyone else, or "clearance" stock of a premium brand, is worth a second look.
2. Compare the packaging with the brand's photos
Broken or re-glued safety seals, blurry print, spelling mistakes, a different font, or a capsule count that does not match the brand's site are common signs of fakes. Check that the lot number and expiry date on the bottle match the box, if there is one. Some brands let you check a lot number with their customer service.
3. Look for independent testing marks, and check them
Marks such as USP Verified or NSF Certified for Sport mean the product was tested by a third party. Fakes copy logos too, so look the product up in the certifier's own online list.
4. What the barcode can and cannot tell you
The last digit of a product barcode is a check digit. If the maths does not add up, the code was misprinted or made up. The first three digits (for example 000–139 for the US and Canada, 690–699 for China) only show which country's GS1 office issued the number, not where the product was made. Still, a US brand whose barcode was issued somewhere unexpected is a good reason to compare it with the barcode on the brand's own site. There is a full table in our barcode country code guide.
5. Stop if you see these on the label
The FDA has warned about ingredients that are not lawful in dietary supplements, including DMAA (1,3-dimethylamylamine), DMHA, BMPEA, phenibut, tianeptine, and SARMs sold for muscle (ostarine, ligandrol, RAD-140 and others). Claims such as "works like a prescription", "steroid results" or "lose 20 pounds in two weeks" are warning signs on their own.
6. Search the official lists
The FDA's Health Fraud Product Database lists products found to contain hidden drug ingredients. Korea's food safety agency keeps a list of blocked overseas products, and Japan's health ministry publishes warnings on unapproved drug products. Not being on a list does not prove a product is safe, but if it is on one, do not buy it.
7. Hidden ingredients cannot be seen
A drug ingredient added in secret is not printed on the label. If you get a racing heart, sleeplessness, a bad headache or dizziness after starting a supplement, stop and talk to a doctor or pharmacist. In the US you can report a problem to the FDA through MedWatch.
8. Be extra careful with "focus" and exam products
No supplement replaces sleep and meals. Attention medicines are prescribed after a medical visit, not bought online like vitamins. Ask a paediatrician or pharmacist before giving any supplement to a child.
What QR Doctor can and cannot do
QR Doctor is a QR code and barcode scanner. Scan the product barcode on a supplement bottle and it shows the number and takes you straight to a web search, so you can compare the listing photos with the brand's own site. Its text scanner (the Aa button on the scan screen) reads a printed ingredient list so you can copy an ingredient name and look it up in the official lists above. Everything runs on your phone; nothing is uploaded.
No app can tell real from fake from a photo. Drug ingredients that are not printed on the label can only be found by a lab test. Use the app to make the checks faster, not as a verdict.
New in QR Doctor 1.6, Label check: scan a product barcode and the result shows whether the check digit adds up, which country's GS1 office issued the number (not where it was made) and whether it is a store-only code. Read an English ingredient list with the text scanner and it flags ingredients regulators have warned about (DMAA, phenibut, SARMs and others), with a button to the official lookup for your country.